That was it! I set it to port 80 and the NTP set the clock correct to my zip code.
I did do a reset and the port defaults to 80, but then I reset the port to 90 to access the menu through the web interface. I wanted to use a port that isn’t so obvious.
This also explains why my Wunderground wasn’t making the expected adjustments and sometimes coming up blank.
Is there a chance this will be fixed in future updates?